Two Top Trucks Square Off: Compare the 2018 Toyota Tacoma to the 2018 Chevy Colorado in Yorkville

In years gone by, the humble pickup truck was primarily used only by farmers, contractors, and blue-collar workers. Beloved for its stability, structure, and strength, but not a popular for Utica, Rome, Whitesboro, Herkimer NY drivers who wanted a fun, comfortable vehicle. But, times have changed, and brands like Toyota and Chevy have pulled out all the stops to deliver comfort, performance, safety, and strength--all in a convenient, midsize pickup package.

The 2018 Toyota Tacoma and the 2018 Chevrolet Silverado are both exciting new options for New York drivers.

Not sure which will be the better fit for your lifestyle in and around Yorkville? We've done some of the legwork for you, and compared the Tacoma vs Colorado in a few of the areas that NY truck drivers are going to care about the most.

Price & Value

When shopping for your next small truck in Utica, price and the vehicle's value (both now and down the road) are probably important factors for you to consider. Both Chevy and Toyota boast strong reputations for making durable and solid trucks, but Toyota comes out a little bit ahead. Price tag varies a lot based on trim/configuration/powertrain, so be sure to consider a variety of options.

  • Tacoma is consistently ranked as a top choice for Best Resale Value--the Colorado is still pretty untested
  • Colorado does have a lower starting price, but that base model was really only designed to be a bare-bones work truck. You won't get much from it--not even carpeting. Seriously.
  • The base Tacoma SR is affordable and nicely-equipped for the price

Towing & Performance

We can be honest: nobody is buying a midsize, light-duty truck to haul livestock trailers or huge boats. So, don't expect any jaw-dropping towing and payload numbers here. However, both the Tacoma and Colorado offer enough power and muscle for Oneonta hobbyists and all of their gear.

  • Both Colorado and Tacoma offer a standard four-cylinder engine on entry-level models, and an optional V-6 engine on upper-level models
  • Max tow ratings for both gas-powered V6 trucks is comparable
  • Both offer off-road-specific model options: the 2018 Tacoma TRD Pro and the 2018 Colorado ZR2

Features & Fun

Power is great--fun is better. There's a good change that 80-90% of the driving that you'll do in your new truck will be commuting, running errands, and waiting in traffic during Oneida rush hour. So, you better make sure that you get a midsize truck that you're going to enjoy. Both the 2018 Tacoma and 2018 Colorado can be equipped with tons of feature packages.

  • As mentioned above, the entry-level Tacoma SR dominates the Colorado Base in features; choose a well-equipped Colorado, and you'll be paying through the nose
  • Love that open-sky feeling? The 2018 Tacoma offers an available moonroof that you won't find on any Colorado model
  • The 2018 Tacoma comes loaded with surprising features--like a standard GoPro mount--to make it the most adventure-ready midsize truck

Safety & Security

Safety isn't always sexy--but since a well-constructed frame and a smart suite of security features could make all the difference in the event of an accident, this is something important to consider when shopping around for truck lease deals and finance offers in NY.

  • The 2018 Tacoma is the only vehicle in its class to offer standard Pre-Collision System, a Lane Departure Alert System, Adaptive Cruise Control, and Automatic High Beam Headlights
  • Toyota's standard safety system offers way more features than any standard option on entry-level Colorado trucks
  • The 2018 Tacoma boasts better safety ratings from the IIHS than the Colorado does--by far


  • Monday 9:00AM - 7:00PM
  • Tuesday 9:00AM - 7:00PM
  • Wednesday 9:00AM - 7:00PM
  • Thursday 9:00AM - 7:00PM
  • Friday 9:00AM - 6:00PM
  • Saturday 9:00AM - 5:00PM
  • Sunday Closed


Steet Toyota of Yorkville

4991 Commercial Dr
Directions Yorkville, NY 13495

  • Sales: (315) 736-8241
  • Service: (315) 736-8241
  • Parts: (315) 736-8241

Make an Inquiry